Let’s face it, people simply can’t wait weeks or even days for working AC in the desert. Later in 2007, Ingersoll Rand bought Trane, acquiring the Trane and American Standard brand names. The parent company of the Trane and American Standard brands is the manufacturing giant Ingersoll Rand. In Phoenix, Trane was once a little more selective about who became a Trane dealer than the 3rd party wholesaler. The replacement warranty is 10 years, 5, 3 or 1 year depending on the AC. American Standard is a well-known brand but is most typically associated with plumbing fixtures and products. Livingston v. Trane U.S. Inc., No. Almost every major HVAC manufacturer sells the same equipment under different brand names. Magic Touch Mechanical was a “Trane Comfort Specialist Dealer” for more than 15-years. Here’s the real deal. 5). Is American Standard better than Trane? Feedback I have heard is Tranes are more expensive to repair, and a bit of a pain as well. They spend a significant amount of marketing dollars making sure consumers know it is a premium brand. Ingersoll Rand goes to market with the Trane brand a little differently than they do with American Standard. Is the higher cost a sign of better quality? High-speed is used for rapid cooling when the thermostat setting has been lowered. Later in 2007, Ingersoll Rand bought Trane, acquiring the Trane and American Standard brand names. So, we switched to the American Standard wholesaler who promised better service. High-speed is used for rapid cooling when the thermostat setting has been lowered. The downsides: The main disadvantage with models from Trane is that the one-stage models can be noisy with a noise level of 75 dB. Trane XR17 is the only two-stage model in the more-affordable XR Series. Additionally, Trane makes 2 models that American Standard does not make. However, our air conditioning & heating system install department has long been the busiest department in our company. When there is a problem it’s quick easy and cheap to repair. Variable-capacity ACs are the most efficient and provide the best indoor climate control. All Rights Reserved. Final Thoughts on ASM’s Trane vs Lennox Air Conditioner Review. Magic Touch Mechanical switched from Trane to American Standard and back again in our 23-year history with the brand(s). is part of the “i” series. They are the most affordable way to cool, though your home might experience temperature swings that are slightly noticeable. But there’s a more complex, important answer: Here are five steps to buying a new central air conditioner. offers a Lifetime unit replacement warranty on its best three ACs. AS didn't make the top 10 In AC's Niether lennox or AS made the top 10 (according to the reviews). All the data is the same for the 7 identical models. If you’d like more information about these brands, their ACs and air conditioner cost, our buying guides will help. So, if you’re trying to decide American Standard or Trane, you should be asking yourself, Contractor A vs. Remember, since we’re a larger than the average HVAC Company, we install a lot of air conditioning and heating units. This means if either fails during the replacement period, the entire AC will be replaced, not just the failed part. Ameristar has a full line of affordable systems at a price point that will keep you and your client homeowners happy while providing long-lasting comfort. This means if either fails during the replacement period, the entire AC will be replaced, not just the failed part. What justifies the higher cost, even if its slight? The more equipment a contractor purchases, the lower the cost of each individual unit. Always a pioneering company, Trane produced its first air conditioning system in 1931, well ahead of the curve. Poor duct design and installation will cause even the best, ***** ***** most durable and reputable furnaces on the market to fail prematurely. American Standard Companies divided into three divisions. A settlement has been reached on behalf of nearly 500,000 current and former owners of Trane and American Standard air conditioners manufactured with an unapproved rust inhibitor that caused many units to fail. They run at full capacity whenever on. Trane is one of the most well-known HVAC brands and offers some of the most energy-efficient heat pumps on the market. Aside from that difference the rest of the equipment lineup and components are identical. are two-stage central air conditioners. Ask a contractor about American Standard vs Trane air conditioners! Under the agreement, Ingersoll Rand separated its Industrial segment and combined with Gardner Denver. American Standard has a reputation as a premium brand, one of America’s oldest manufacturer of household products including plumbing fixtures. But there’s a more complex, important answer: Find the best air conditioner installer for any brand you choose. Full disclosure; Trane charges dealers a “marketing fund” in many areas, which is attached to each piece of equipment purchased. If they sell Trane, then Trane is the right choice. About Us | Contact Us | Privacy Policy. American Standard vs Trane. Other examples include Goodman, Daikin & Amana (same manufacturer), Carrier & Bryant (same manufacturer) and Rheem & Ruud (same manufacturer). The HVAC division was renamed Trane. While the Vortica ™ II Blower is regarded as one of the most efficient in the industry, this two-stage furnace has a gas efficiency rating of 97% AFUE. The second number is the general parts warranty for other functional parts. In order to protect distribution deals between Ingersoll Rand and their suppliers’ contractors are only supposed to sell one or the other. Some brands call ACs like this “compact” models. If you choose a cut-rate installer to save money, and your air conditioner fails in just a few years, you’ll lose all your savings and more. If the compressor ever fails, Amana will replace the entire air conditioner. Not only are both brands manufactured in the same facility (in Tyler, Texas), they go down the same assembly line. DECIBAL RATINGS (Sound) Note: The lower the number the quieter it is. These brands are known for quality and prices that are both above average. models are single-stage air conditioners. However, we buy some of the other brands and products they carry. Lennox comes in at 8th. Learn More with American Standard and Trane Buying Guides. So, if you assume Trane costs more than American Standard, you might be wrong…it depends on where you buy it. In fact, they are within a few dollars of each other model by model. The answer is that their shorter warranties and higher costs allow them to maximize profits, even if they lose a few sales along the way. Under the American Standard name, the DuraTuff top can be purchased at an additional cost, and field installed. It’s important to note; that marketing fee doesn’t necessarily mean the contractor is paying more for Trane than American Standard. James Trane, an immigrant from Norway, founded Trane in 1885 to produce steam-driven home heating equipment. The company is a subsidiary of Trane Technologies and is the successor company to the American Standard Companies.It makes products under the Trane and American Standard brand names. Carrier recently (March 2020) split off from United Technologies … American Standard was the first to offer the 12-year warranty on the compressor. If you need an AC now or want a more convenient process, our Free Local Quotes service is available. Combine with the American Standard AccuClean™ Air Cleaner for a cleaner, healthier, and more comfortable home; Download the Product Brochure Models Available. Trane makes 7 air conditioners that are identical in all but name to the 7 American Standard models. Not even close. It has continued to produce equipment under both names. Great idea on getting an estimate on American Standard, as from what I can see, they are rated higher than Trane, although part of the same company. We also purchase lots of installation materials and supplies through that wholesaler. Goodman used to offer the warranty. American Standard Gold S9V2-VS Introducing an updated cabinet, the Gold S9V2-VS is designed to accommodate almost any Canadian home. You pay a bit more, but get an air conditioner that should run longer without mechanical issues compared with most other brands. The only products manufactured under the Trane brand are air conditioning and heating systems & accessories. Is the Trane better than the American Standard, or is the American Standard better than the Trane? When you find a qualified installer, a Trane and American Standard air conditioner should give you 20+ years of service. The difference in these units is that they have variable-speed fans. Well it all started with getting an Ecobee for Christmas, about 12 hours later I found out that it doesn't work with the current 4 wire system used by my Coleman "communicating system". (hole in coil outside) 1 - American standard vs Rheem. Magic Touch, while not huge, is larger than the average HVAC contracting / home service company according to statistics. I have used carrier/Bryant/Payne for 20 years. This will be a quick read because there are only two differences: The parent company of the Trane and American Standard brands is the manufacturing giant Ingersoll Rand. Receive free quotes too! However, installation alone for a new air conditioner can cost anywhere from $1,800-$10,500. In some parts of the country the brands are distributed through wholesalers, in other areas it’s factory direct. Does common ownership mean their central air conditioners are identical? The air conditioning part of the business is often called “American Standard Air” and it has its own website , separate from the American Standard site which promotes and sells its bathroom and kitchen products. After years of selling Trane we found the service we were receiving from the Phoenix Trane Sales Office was diminishing. Copyright © 2014-2021, PICKHVAC All Rights Reserved. Trane XV20i – up to 22 SEER. Likewise there are great Trane dealers as well, however more than a few that are, well…not so great. We offer a lot more services than just air conditioning installation. Better yet, let’s sit down and compare Trane to their competition side-by-side. For those who want an affordable system, Trane has the XB series. Still, it’s a stretch to call warranties from Trane and American Standard “top of the line.”. While I've read countless times that installation and quality of work matters more than brand, considering the same level of install, is it worth the investment to pay say a 15% premium for American Standard equipment? It’s all part of our philosophy of offering “Options not Ultimatums”, and the reason we offer many brands. American Standard Platinum 20 – up to 22 SEER. The Trane name seems to hold more weight locally amongst the general public than its sister brand. At that time, the American Standard brand could be purchased by practically any licensed HVAC Contractor. On the same note; we have a large vehicle fleet, offices, uniformed technicians, a training facility for our technicians, etc. American Standard (NYSE: ASD) is a global manufacturer with market-leading positions in three businesses: air conditioning systems and service, sold under the Trane and American Standard brands for commercial, institutional and residential buildings; plumbing products, sold under such brands as American Standard and Ideal Standard; and vehicle control systems, including electronic braking … As noted, there are seven identical ACs made by the brands, plus two more from Trane. American Standard vs Trane: The truth about how much they cost. Take it from a contractor who’s switched between being a Trane Dealer and an American Standard Dealer over the years: The equipment cost is virtually the same between the two brand names. It’s available on select models. Note: The first warranty number is the warranty for the compressor and outdoor coil (condensing coil). In our humble opinion, Trane wins our Trane vs Lennox air conditioner review. It has continued to produce equipment under both names. Choosing the right company and assuring the unit is installed correctly is more important than the brand, model, or efficiency. One of the changes Ingersoll Rand made when taking over included installing a new management team in Phoenix. 1875: American Standard has roots back to two innovative companies that merged in the early 20th C. The history is detailed on Wikipedia. So, American Standard bought Trane and then became Trane. Expect minor repairs after 10 to 12 years. Now that you know I’m definitely qualified to answer the question of American Standard vs Trane you’ve been searching for: The only exception to that statement is the condensing unit top that comes on a few of the high-efficiency condenser models. That said, there are a number of great contractors who’ve been selling American Standard in Phoenix for many years. At some point, usually after year 15, you’ll need to decide whether making a costly repair is worth the money or you’ll be better off buying a new AC. American Standard does not have an exact pricing breakdown of its units readily available, since many factors affect the cost. ICP brands Heil, Tempstar and others offer complete unit replacement warranties on compressors and coils. Low profile: The Silver 16 and XR16 Low Profile single stage units have smaller footprints and cabinets. Trane; Bryant; Heatpumppricingguides.com compares heat pumps prices for 3-ton systems. American Standard air conditioner pricing . The compressors run at modulating capacity between 40% and 100%. The more access we have to parts, the faster service we can deliver to our clients. The Low Profile ACs are designed for installation where space is limited. is the only two-stage model in the more-affordable XR Series. Under the Trane name, these models are equipped with the DuraTuff top. Just remember that the installation and duct design is the MOST IMPORTANT part of the system. Again, the major difference in the brands is the distribution network, which varies throughout the country. Trane and other brands like American Standard are among the few manufacturers that engineers their compressors. Some brands and suppliers will let anyone with a pulse purchase their equipment, while others are more selective in who becomes an “official dealer” in order to protect “the brand”. However, all third-party industry experts say the most important part of the equation for the consumer is the installing company. Nor does it mean the consumer pays more for that matter. They will answer which brand is better. American Standard is sold through a 3rdparty distributor. Trane makes two 2-stage models to offer customers more options for performance and efficiency: Trane XL16i is part of the “i” series. The company gets far fewer repair calls for its’ AC systems than most of the other AC units in the business. Heil, Tempstar and others offer complete unit replacement warranties on compressors and coils. Price should be a secondary issue. The American Standard Silver and Trane XR13 to XR16 models are single-stage air conditioners. We want to give people the products and options they want…not what we want to sell. The replacement warranty is 10 years, 5, 3 or 1 year depending on the AC. Select the company you believe will do the best job installing your central AC. If the compressor ever fails, Amana will replace the entire air conditioner. That purchasing power reflects how much we pay for the equipment and what we can sell it for. 2:17-cv-06480-ES-MAH (D.N.J.) 1982: Trane acquired General Electric’s HVAC division and slapped the Trane name on everything it made. 2). Longer warranty? 4). Frankly, poor management led to the issues us contractors like us had with the old Arizona Trane. The brand is well revered and many homeowners ask for Trane by name. The air conditioning and heating contractor (dealer) naturally needs to add that into their cost of goods sold. They speed up or slow down to deliver the precise amount of air conditioning to keep your home’s temperature balanced. Unless the Trane dealer is willing to match his proposal to the American Standard dealer's, I'd pursue the American Standard option. Carrier and Bryant Gas Furnaces. Here in the Valley of the Sun, Trane’s marketing efforts have worked out quite well for them. The reason being, they can increase market share while honoring distribution exclusivity contracts with different wholesalers. offer 12-year total parts warranties that includes 12-year unit replacement on the compressor. Heres a question were asked by customers who are fresh off their computers after Googling air conditioner brands. Purchasing a new heating and cooling system is a major investment for homeowners and can put a significant dent in budgets. These models are divided into three performance levels. American Standard is solid equipment that I don't often see in houses due to Trane being the more predominant name, but it is good equipment nonetheless. The reason we offer several different brands when proposing a new air conditioning system installation is: We believe in promoting Magic Touch Mechanical, not the manufacturer’s brand. Goodman used to offer the warranty. However, in other parts of the country, the roles are reversed. 1984: Trane was suddenly a hot commodity, and in 1984, American Standard bought the brand. The manufacturer simply must keep replacement parts in stock locally! Again, I’ve seen it myself multiple times. A little perspective so you know who’s providing the information herein: I founded Magic Touch Mechanical in Mesa, AZ over 20-years ago in 1997. We’ve installed their air conditioners, heat pumps, furnaces, air handlers, coils and accessories. The table below shows the list of brands, their efficiency, performance and features. The Low Profile ACs are designed for installation where space is limited. Update March, 2020: In April 2019, Ingersoll Rand and Industrial Manufacturer, Gardner Denver announced the two companies would merge under the name Ingersoll Rand and the Trane brand would no longer be part of the Ingersoll Rand family of brands. Frankly, if we could offer the unit under both brand names we would, but I understand the reasoning. That practice was nixed in the last few years because consumers demand better warranty coverage. This will NEVER affect our opinion of a product or service! Compare their estimates. Amana offers a Lifetime unit replacement warranty on its best three ACs. On February 1, 2007, American Standard Companies announced it would break up its three divisions. I share that only to express that we install a lot of new air conditioning units. Aside from Trane, we also install Lennox, Goodman, Bosch, Mitsubishi & Fujitsu… to name a few. In Phoenix, Trane is distributed factory-direct whereas American Standard is distributed through a wholesaler. Nowadays, there doesn’t seem to be much selectivity from the manufacturers like there was in the old days, they’re all racing to increase marketshare. As a result, we have a lot of purchasing power. BRAND NEW OEM Trane/American Standard GE Genteq 4-Speed Furnace Blower Motor. Contractor B! This is a brand new Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Trane American Standard contactor relay 2-pole 24 volt 30amp, part# CTR02573 (also# CTR2573) Replaces the following part #'s: CTR2573, CTR02573, 8910DP32V14, HCCY2XQ02AA318, C147094P03 When you compare American Standard vs Carrier, you'll find that American Standard, also referred to as Trane, offers three different series of air AC units for the home: Platinum series. Contractors can sell one brand or the other, but not both. In fact…. Interview each individually. While most people can recite Trane’s slogan off the top of their heads – “Nothing Stops a Trane”, nobody really knows American Standard’s slogan…including myself! When there’s an issue we are “on our clients side” not the manufacturers side. Condenser fan needs assistance to start american standard heritage 14 heat pum . Some contractors may charge more for Trane than for American Standard…or visa-versa/ However, this most likely has more to do with that company’s overhead than the price of the equipment. We service all brands of air conditioning units including American Standard. In 1967, the company shortened its merged name to American Standard. However, technical support and service “direct” from the manufacturer is often stronger than it is from a 3rd party who also sells other brands. We rely on readers like you to share your HVAC system cost or quote. IR acquired the company (formerly The Trane Company) in June 2008 for a reported $10.1 billion. Several of their heat pump models boast efficiencies up to 20.0 SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) and 12.0 HSPF (Heating Seasonal Performance Factor). The Platinum series includes the most popular units for home heating and air. The price should be around about a $1000 less than a Trane/American Standard of same specs. Manufacturers typically have more resources available than 3rd party supply houses. They are ideal for installation on a patio or under a deck. 5). They run at full capacity whenever on. Trane vs american standard air conditioner review trane warranty. Third party suppliers and the manufacturers have contracts that allow for exclusivity, which is only fair for the suppliers. Trane’s was 10 years, and that justified slightly lower cost for Trane. The extra cost of the i Series models is $85 to $150 when compared with models with single-stage fans. have variable-speed compressors. The HVAC division was renamed Trane. Amana $5,400; American Standard $7,800; Armstrong $4,600; Carrier $8,000; Coleman $5,300; Goodman $4,600; Lennox $6,700; Rheem $5,000; Trane $8,600; York $4,700 Besides Trane, we also install Lennox, Mitsubishi, Fujitsu, Bosch and a few others. The GE part number is 5KCP39HGS599S. Carrier vs Bryant vs Day & Night Air Conditioner Review: What’re the Differences Between These 3 Sister Brands, Trane Air Handler Price, Review and Buying Guide. Better dealer support means a better experience for our clients. The shaft is 1/2″ diameter and 3″ long- if the shaft is facing up, as seen in the picture, rotation is Clock-Wise. We may or may not be compensated for purchased you make as a result of our recommendation. Now, both brands offer 12 years on the compressor and coil. Differences in Trane TEM6/8 vs. TAM9? Keep it maintained. So, our overhead is higher than a smaller company that operates out of the owner’s home. Amana VS Goodman Air Conditioner Review: Is There Any Difference Between Them? There are two advantages to a variable-speed fan that matches its speed to the speed of the compressor – It uses less electricity and is 3-5 decibels quieter when running on low speed. American Standard air conditioners are one of the best central air conditioning brands in the business. Each have some unique features that may better suit one over the other based on the application. Really, the only reason was to assure the best experience we could for our clients. This table allows you to compare the product lines at a glance. This is completely different from market to market, but in Phoenix the difference could be the caliber of dealer. Here are five steps to buying a new central air conditioner. Trane American Standard Contactor Relay CTR2573 CTR02573 C147094P03. Here’s why: First, I should mention we still do business with the 3rd party distributor who sells American Standard in Phoenix. We’ve installed tens-of-thousands throughout the Greater Phoenix area over the last two decades. Trane was suddenly a hot commodity, and in 1984, American Standard bought the brand. single stage units have smaller footprints and cabinets. As a result, there’s a lot of misinformation being spread to the public by contractors and their salespeople especially. York and Goodman rank as the top 2 (according to the reviews) in furnaces. Comparison of American Standard AUC1B060A9361A and Trane TUD2B060A9362A based on specifications, reviews and ratings. There is little debate in the HVAC industry that bad installation is the leading cause of premature air conditioner failure (or heat pump or furnace). Ultimately that cost is passed on to the consumer just like any other product. We explain why that has changed in our. They are ideal for installation on a patio or under a deck. We explain why that has changed in our Amana vs Goodman Review, which is similar to this Trane vs American Standard Review. American Standard Platinum line, ZM air conditioner. It’s important to know, we aren’t biased one way or the other as we also install many competing brands. Bottom line: It’s extremely important to research the caliber of the installing HVAC Contractor. The HVAC division was renamed Trane. The American Standard Platinum 20 and Platinum 18 and the Trane XV20i and XV18 have variable-speed compressors. It really helps other visitors to estimate the cost of a new HVAC unit. This leads to differences in the contractor’s experience – and ultimately the end users experience with the brand. We chose these brands based on quality, reliability, and features. American standard allegiance 13 air conditioners. You’ll notice I referred to the manufacturing facility of both brand names as one, that was no accident. Trane vs American Standard Air Conditioner Review; Don’t Overpay for Trane or Lennox: SHOW ME TRANE AND LENNOX PRICES. 2007: American Standard Companies divided into three divisions. 2007: American Standard Companies divided into three divisions. If you need an AC now or want a more convenient process, our, It is convenient – you fill out one form and receive written estimates from 3 contractors, The HVAC companies are pre-screened to ensure they are experienced, licensed and insured, There is no cost for using the service, and you’re under no obligation to hire any of the companies that give you an estimate, Trane, American Standard and Ingersoll Rand, Trane and American Standard Air Conditioners, Trane and American Standard Warranty Coverage, Which Brand is Better: Trane vs American Standard ACs, American Standard AC Guide and Latest Prices, Carrier Heat Pump Prices and Reviews 2020, Trane Central Air Conditioner Reviews and Prices 2020, American Standard Air Conditioner Reviews And Prices 2020, Lennox Gas Furnace Reviews and Prices 2020, Carrier Air Conditioner Reviews and Prices 2020, Lennox Air Conditioner Reviews and Prices 2020, Payne Air Conditioner Reviews And Prices 2020, Goodman Heat Pump Prices and Reviews 2020, Goodman Air Conditioner Reviews & Prices (March 2020), Rheem Air Conditioner Reviews and Prices 2020, Ruud Air Conditioner Reviews and Prices 2020, Amana Central Air Conditioner Reviews and Prices 2020, Amana/Daikin Heat Pump Reviews and Prices 2020, American Standard Gas Furnace Prices and Reviews 2020, American Standard Heat Pump Prices and Reviews 2020, Trane vs Carrier vs Lennox Air Conditioner Review 2020, Trane vs Carrier vs Lennox Furnace Review 2020.